Most writing advice is about finishing. Get it done. Push through the middle. Don’t abandon the draft. Trust the process, even when the process feels like walking through wet concrete in shoes that don’t fit.
All reasonable. All worth following, most of the time.
But there is another kind of writing that never gets defended, and it deserves a moment. The writing that goes nowhere. The story started on a Tuesday that you forgot about by Thursday. The character sketched out in a notebook who never made it into anything. The first three chapters of something that turned out not to have a fourth chapter in it. The journal entries, the freewriting, the fragments that felt urgent at the time and now sit in folders with names like “misc old” and “don’t delete maybe” that you haven’t opened since the year you made them.
This writing is not wasted. Not any of it.
It is practice, first of all.
Every sentence written, even the ones that lead nowhere, is a sentence that made you slightly better at writing sentences. This sounds too simple to be true and it is completely true. Writing is a physical skill as much as an intellectual one. The hand, the eye, the instinct for rhythm and pacing — these improve through repetition whether or not the thing you’re repeating ends up going anywhere useful. Musicians practice scales that never appear in a performance. Athletes run distances that aren’t part of any race. Writers write things that don’t become books, and the writing makes them better at the writing that does.
The abandoned drafts are the scales. They count.
It is also exploration.
Not every idea needs to become a finished thing to have been worth following. Some ideas need to be written three pages into before you discover they’re not what you thought. That discovery is useful. It clears the way. It tells you something important about what you’re actually interested in versus what you thought you were interested in, which are not always the same thing and the sooner you know the difference the better.
The idea that seemed brilliant in the abstract sometimes reveals itself, on the page, to be thin. Better to find that out three pages in than thirty. The writing that goes nowhere has saved more writers from worse fates than any amount of outlining.
It keeps the habit alive.
There will be periods where the main project is stuck, finished, between things, or simply too heavy to pick up on a given day. The writing that goes nowhere is what you do instead. A character who might become something. A scene with no context. Three pages of a voice you’re trying out just to see what it sounds like.
This kind of writing asks nothing of you. There’s no pressure attached to it because it isn’t going anywhere. And that freedom, paradoxically, is sometimes where the most interesting things happen. When you’re not trying to produce anything, you stop performing and start playing. The writing relaxes. So do you. Things come out that wouldn’t have come out under the weight of a real project with real expectations.
Some writers keep a separate notebook specifically for this. No project, no goal, no plan. Just writing for the sake of it. It sounds indulgent. It is slightly indulgent. It is also one of the most useful things you can do.
And occasionally, years later, you find something.
You open one of those abandoned folders on a slow afternoon, not looking for anything in particular, and there it is. A character you’d completely forgotten about who is exactly right for the thing you’re working on now. A line that’s better than anything you’ve written recently and you have no memory of writing it. An idea that didn’t work then, in that form, at that point in your life, but suddenly makes complete sense now that you’re a different writer with a different set of tools and a different understanding of what you were actually trying to say.
This happens more than people talk about. The abandoned work doesn’t stay abandoned forever. It waits. It turns up when you need it, like a note you wrote to your future self without knowing that’s what you were doing.
Nothing is wasted. The folders full of unfinished things are not a record of failure. They are an archive. A compost heap, if you want to be less romantic about it, where old things break down and become the soil for new ones.
Keep writing the things that go nowhere. You don’t always get to know, at the time, which ones those are.
Leave a Reply