And yet here we are.
Books about writing. Courses about writing. Podcasts, workshops, MFA programmes, YouTube channels, Reddit threads, Twitter threads, Substack newsletters written by writers about writing instead of actually writing. The advice industry around writing is enormous, which is funny when you consider that the one thing everyone in it agrees on is that the only way to learn is to sit down and do it.
So why do we keep looking for shortcuts? Why does every writer, at some point, find themselves three hours deep into a podcast about someone else’s creative process instead of working on their own?
Because writing is uncomfortable and podcasts are not. That’s the whole answer. You can dress it up but that’s what it is.
The uncomfortable thing about writing, the thing the advice industry quietly glosses over, is that it requires you to have something to say. Not a plot. Not a premise. Not a concept that sounds good when you describe it at a dinner party. Something you actually think, feel, believe, or want to understand. Something with enough weight to sustain thousands of words of attention.
This is the part nobody can give you. The craft can be learned. The voice develops with practice. The structure can be studied and understood and eventually applied without thinking about it. But the thing underneath all of it, the reason to write this particular thing rather than any other, that has to come from you. Nobody can put it there.
Which is terrifying, if you think about it too long. So most of us don’t think about it too long. We take another course instead.
Here is what the best writing advice actually does, when it works. It doesn’t teach you how to write. It reminds you of things you already knew and talked you out of during a long period of self-doubt. It gives language to instincts you had but didn’t trust. It shows you that the problems you thought were unique to you are the same problems everyone has, which is not a solution but is at least a comfort.
That’s genuinely useful. A writer who feels less alone in the difficulty is a writer who might keep going. And keeping going is most of it.
The dirty secret of all writing advice, including this, is that it works best after you’ve already done the thing. Read a book about craft before you’ve written anything and it’s abstract, theoretical, faintly intimidating. Read the same book after you’ve struggled through a first draft and suddenly every page is a revelation because now you have the experience to hang the advice on. The advice hasn’t changed. You have.
This is why writers read books about writing for their entire careers. Not because they haven’t learned enough yet. Because they keep becoming different writers with different problems, and the same advice keeps meaning something new.
So read the books. Listen to the podcasts. Take the course if it makes you feel ready. Just know that ready is a feeling writing gives you, not a feeling that leads to writing. The only way in is through the door, and the door is just sitting down and starting, badly, without knowing how it ends, with no guarantee that any of it will work.
Everyone who has ever written anything started there.
You’re in good company.
Leave a Reply